My Body, My Rules! For Now..
May 9th, 2007 by Nancy ClevelandLike the majority of the populace, I have an allopathic physician. As with many of the populace…particularly in the last twenty years or so, I’ve been an advocate of homeopathy, herbals, acupuncture, massage therapy and, yes…the proven granny’s remedies, the proverbial “old wives†treatments for what ails one and I write this not as a practitioner but as a consumer.
When I lived in Maryland back in the early to mid ‘90’s, I had acupuncture treatments (including Chinese herbal medication) once every week for over a year. Complimentary to that, I took massage therapy once a week for over three years and greatly benefited from both modalities. In fact, never felt better in my life…either before or since and the only reason I haven’t undertaken either since being here is…well, silly but true. It’s as difficult to change a successful and trusted healer, such as those two, as it generally is having to change a trusted MD. But in recent months I have been strongly considering finding similar practitioners here. On my own, I research the “alternative†modalities and continue to use the herbals, energy work etc. so it came as quite a disturbing shock to me, listening to Dan’s discussion with Gertie this morning…and learning that there is a Bill ready to change…no, to remove the choice of how I nurture and treat my OWN body. Yes…MY body!
Allopathic physicians certainly have their place as do dietitians and nutritionists choosing to come under a government blanket. Let them have it…but do they have the right to dictate whom I wish to consult? Depending upon whether or not we have medical insurance co-pay, no medical insurance, pharmacologic coverage our medical treatments are not free or cheap and it seems to me since I must pay whatever the going rate is, I ought to maintain the right to spend it where I choose. And, frankly, it’s my opinion…and experience…that anyone having a required license is no guarantee to quality or successful care. My massage therapist in MD, for instance, was not board certified…when she began her practice there was no such thing as licensing for massage therapists. Her clientele came from all walks of life and were so numerous it was often more difficult to secure an appointment with her than it was with a physician. Additionally, many of her clients benefited so much from their treatments that they went on to become massage therapists themselves…the consensus being that they wished to help others as much as they had been helped. I never looked around her office for a certification of any kind. She came highly recommended to me by a very reputable Physical Therapist, among others. After my first couple of treatments, I had no doubt about her ability. Yet, I had a friend…also a client of her’s…who decided to enter the profession which, by then required board certification, took the classes, became certified and even after several years, didn’t even come close. As I said, a license is not necessarily a guarantee.
I’m angry at the very idea a practitioner of herbals, homeopathy, dietary or any other modality may, in the future, be unable to discuss or suggest our preferred method of treatments because of a threat of fines or arrest. This is not even banal enough to term ridiculous…it’s nothing short of criminal and to my somewhat cynical eye, removing this freedom is the first step towards the FDA and Pharm Society succeeding in eliminating anything they do not consider medically proven. Which is odd since few, if any, of the aforementioned alternative routes cause harm while we certainly cannot state that all medically approved drugs/treatments don’t. And, by the way, THEY are licensed! One only has to watch a couple of hours of tv during a day or evening to find the ads for prescription medications which tout the benefits but follow each one with a long list of disclaimers and eye-popping side-effects, some of them fatal. I don’t know about you but each time I view those things I have to wonder…â€Who in their right mind would trade an ache, pain, sleepless night for those possibilities??â€
Please write your State Reps and ask them not to sign on to HB38. Even if you are not “into†alternative treatments or modalities, it IS another freedom of choice we stand to lose should it pass.
May 9th, 2007 at 12:50 pm
i agree so long as there are consumer protections. any claims they make must be true and if they prove not to be they can and should be sued. of course, they ought not to make any claims they cant back up.
May 9th, 2007 at 2:03 pm
But what are consumer protections protecting us against? Only question with “truth”, commonsense, is whose truth? I’m not suggesting believe in miracles (but, hey…open to it, why not) but why discount the ‘anecdotal’. If people employ Ayurvedic, Oriental temperament, Bach remedies and…ahem, sorry…common sense, feel better, get relief, believe themselves to be better, then…aren’t they? But, sure…what about the consumer protections already in place with allopathic medicine. How often are people tested for underlying liver or kidney problems before being dispensed prescriptions which would have adverse effects on either organ…by licensed practitioners? How does one know, prior to taking a prescription, whether or not side-effects will be troublesome. “Take two aspirin and call me in the morning…” yet there are those in whom aspirin has an ill-effect; “finish this course of antibiotics” and neither physicians or pharmacists tell you..’by the way, lay off the dairy products”. Medicines for hypertension…some of them lose their effectiveness if one drinks a glass of grapefruit juice but who tells us this. Not the people who are licensed to dispense the drug.
I do understand your point and that would work for you but I don’t want what works for someone else legally enforced for me where my health and well-being are concerned.
May 9th, 2007 at 2:39 pm
if you believe it worked for you, you wouldnt have any complaint. If an accupuncturist claims that a regimen of weekly sessions will cure my pain in 2 months, then it doesn’t shouldnt i have some recourse?
May 9th, 2007 at 3:59 pm
You do…you can simply just go to an allopathic physician and take whatever treatment he or she says is the standard or traditional form of care for whatever ails you and take the same chances…but if it doesn’t work you have a choice to sue if that’s the recourse you have in mind. Traditional meds work well for some, not so much for others so alternatives are then tried. We don’t take recourse against a physician because we have no positive response to one pill or the other or find ourselves having an adverse reaction to it, true? Given the nature of acupuncture…as per your example…I honestly don’t know any reputable acupuncturist who would make such a claim in any case.
May 10th, 2007 at 3:20 pm
This return to herbs, lotions and other “alternative” forms of health care is absurd.
Remeber Ms. Cleveland, we tried potions and herbs before the advent of modern medical science, and as I recall, it was a disaster. Right now, we have amazing healing rates of virtually every disease. This is because of modern medicine.
Back when we relied on potions, people died. A lot.
If you ask me, these people pushing “alternative medicine” are the same people who used to stadn in a horse cart and sell snake oil. Other than the outifts they wear, there is little difference.
This would all be silly, excpet that some people spend their life’s savings on these worthless remedies, and some people even die.
Although massages do feel nice.