DELMARVA POWER OUT OF STATE WIND PLAN The Untold Story

April 10th, 2008 by admin

From Jim Lanard, Director of Strategic Planning and Communications for Bluewater Wind:

Bluewater Wind’s offshore wind park is an investment in Delaware’s future by improving Delaware’s environment, providing much needed electric generation reliability and creating hundreds of “green collar” jobs for Delawareans.  While it may be that the out-of-state wind bids Delmarva Power has solicited cost less, they will not provide these same benefits for Delaware.  Replacing Bluewater Wind’s instate wind park with wind generated in Illinois, Kentucky, Michigan, western Pennsylvania and Maryland will not create jobs for Delaware, will not enhance reliability and will not have the same environmental benefits for Delaware.

For months now, Delmarva Power has promised to reveal out-of-state wind bids by the end of March, but they now say the new release date won’t be before June 1st.  Delmarva has used the ever-lengthening release date as an effective way to prevent a decision from being made. Bluewater Wind offers the following facts to put Delmarva Power’s apples to oranges comparison into proper perspective.

Delmarva Power’s out-of-state wind energy plan will result in: 

  • Lost Jobs.  Bluewater Wind’s instate wind park will generate 400 – 500 construction jobs and 80 – 100 operations and maintenance jobs for the life of the 25 year contract.  Delmarva Power’s plan will not generate any jobs for Delaware.

  • Lost Economic Hub.  Bluewater Wind will establish Delaware as the economic hub to support the construction of offshore wind parks in the region, if Delaware becomes the first state to approve an offshore wind park.  This economic hub will position Delaware as a national leader in the new clean energy economy attracting other “green collar” jobs — purchasing wind energy from out-of-state will not.
  • Lost Teaching and Training Facility.  Bluewater Wind has committed to supporting a teaching and training program in Delaware, to be launched with a $150,000 grant, so that Delaware can be the training center for workers learning how to build, operate and maintain wind parks.
  • Lost Environmental Benefits.  Bluewater Wind’s offshore wind park will reduce polluting fossil fuel emissions in the Delmarva Peninsula; out-of-state wind won’t.  The National Renewable Energy Labs reports that, “according to the chief operating officer of the PJM  Regional Transmission Organization, wind energy displaced coal-fired generation about 70% of the time in this power market in 2006.”  In addition, offshore turbine foundations become artificial reefs and will benefit coastal aquatic life.
  • Lost reliability.  According to experts hired by the State, the offshore wind park, coupled with the proposed backup facility, will enhance electric reliability in Delaware.  This will help avoid future “brownouts” of the type Delaware endured a few summers ago. Purchasing out-of-state wind energy will not enhance reliability.
  • Hidden costs.  Delmarva Power’s out-of-state wind bid allows bidders to enter the PJM grid at any point on the system, which will likely expose ratepayers to transmission risks and higher costs than advertised due to inefficiency.  In addition, the contract Bluewater Wind negotiated with Delmarva Power guarantees liquidated damages and termination fees if Bluewater Wind does not perform its contractual obligations; the RFP for the out-of-state wind bidders does not require these protections.

5 Responses to “DELMARVA POWER OUT OF STATE WIND PLAN The Untold Story”

  1. John B. Says:

    Bear in mind that this information comes from a representative of Bluewater Wind who does not take a neutral position on the matter but is biased toward his own company.

  2. Roy Toomey Says:

    I believe it’s darn shame that techonology can’t invite a windmill with blades out front & solar panel collection mirrors in back. When wind dies down to calm; the solar panel collection mirrors start up by collecting suns enegry. The wind blows 5 to 10 miles per her than it can alternate power source between windmill & solar panels. When wind blows 20 miles per hour the windmill power starts & solar panel won’t work. I believe people will make fun of this idea. I consider as alternative to gas-powered plants as backup. Let me take shot at nuclear power plant. Do anybody remember the brownout in Florida’s nuclear power plant? If you don’t than somebody has selective memory.

  3. JonMoseley Says:

    Roy Toomey: There is a lot of wind power technology that has not been put into use. I have invented some of it. There are lots of ways to do this differently. However, most of the wind power technology is built by expensive US companies with a limited range of options. Wind power technology is not that difficult (although some of the control units can get sophisticated if you want, and the interface to the power grid can be tricky). Most of the world’s wind power units could be built in Eastern Europe for 1/5th the price. (Remember that they put the first satellite in orbit and the first man in space, and this technology is not all that challenging.)

    But the big problem is lack of funding… the right kind of funding. I have ideas myself, but no money to develop them and test them.

  4. JonMoseley Says:

    Still, I don’t see any reason for Delaware to not hire Delaware workers to build wind power units for Delaware. I agree with Bluewater Wind on that. REMEMBER… the first unit off the assembly line always costs far more than the last. If Delaware can develop the capacity to produce lots of these units, the cost per unit will fall. Look at what happened with laser printers, microwaves, VCR’s, DVD’s. The first real laser printers cost as much as a small economy car. Now, they practically give them away to get you addicted to the ink cartridges. Same can happen with wind power, if someone primes the pump. My arguments above are only that we should not let any obstacle STOP US from harnessing the wind. Whatever it takes…

  5. Outside The Perimeter: HCR38 Edition « kavips Says:

    [...] his time limit, during an interview without pulling the plug…….. Meanwhile, down south, Maria Evans was filtering through the News Journal story as [...]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.